The Good Man
Michael Gurevich
In “Young Goodman Brown” the author uses an omniscient narrative
style to guide the readers through he story. By selecting a
first-person narrative style, the reader is able to understand the
character on a much deeper level.
The sun was setting but I knew I would have to make my leave. My
wife, Faith, was reluctant to see me go but I see no her words would
not be enough to make me stay. I was going for this errand that I
knew was wrong but I was a man of my word so this promise I would have
to keep. “Dearest heart,” She whispered to me as she pleaded for me
to stay. She didn’t want me to go, she was too afraid for my safety
and for her own, as well. She told me she was too fearful of spending
the night alone but I urged her to remain hopeful and to trust in my
words. She she knew of the journey I was embarking on, she would
probably never look at me as the man she sees me now. I bid her adieu
and went off into the night. I arrived at the forest on a night that
seemed darker than any other, I felt this was a sign for me to turn
back but I had to keep to my promise, it was only this one time. As I
walked along the path I saw the shadow of a figure resting on a downed
tree. He called to me in an upset voice “You are late, Goodman
Brown”. I chuckled and told him that my wife, Faith, was so worried
that I lost track of time as I was leaving. This man was dressed
sharply, he didn’t resemble a shadow in the forest but a man who would
likely be respected in all parts of life. “Come, Goodman Brown!” he
called to me as we went on path. Although he seemed confidant and
controlled, the staff that accompanied him was an uncomfortable sight.
A twisted walking stick that had a pattern to it that resembled a
serpent. With every step we made I could feel his it slither beside
us.
I was becoming more and more restless as our journey continued. Not
because of the treacherous path but because of the decisions I made
that night. For you see, I come from a long line of good Christen
men. I arrived with the light and I was planning to remain with it
until my dying day. Tonight, I was planning to descend into the
depths of the earth, straight to the devil’s lair. As we carried on
through the forest I became confused about my decision and decided I
should trust my gut instinct. “I’m going back” I told the fellow
traveler. “I’m going back for Faith’s sake, she needs me”. In
response, the traveler offered me his staff as though my troubles were
merely physical. I declined his offer and decided not to argue with
him but to keep on with my promise and follow him through the path.
The traveler told me that he must take off but that he would leave his
walking stick with me in case I needed it to complete the trip. As he
disappeared into the darkness I heard the voice of my beautiful Faith.
“Faith!” I cried, as I stood up and lunged forward into the forest.
I didn’t know in which direction to go so I trust my heart to guide
me. Running forward I felt a strong force pulling me, as if the
serpent has come alive within the traveler’s staff. It pulled me
through the forest with such force that I could barely feel the ground
below my feet, I was flying toward my love. “Faith!” I yelled out
again, “Faith!, faith!”.
As I made my way out of the forest I saw a community of people
huddled together in a circle, as if in a worship. At this moment I
realized this was the event I originally planned to attend. Through
the crowed of people I noticed all the familiar faces from my small
town. I heard the voice of Deacon Gookin, the minister of our church.
Not too far away was Goody Cloyse, the holiest of women. This wasn’t
the place I wanted to be, nor was this how I imagined these people.
They were no longer good loving people, but rather devil worshipers.
The people of Salem finally revealed their true colors, colors I would
never identify with. As I tried to make haste to flew, I saw my Faith
participating with the wretched of men. “Faith!” I yelled out to her,
“Look up into the heavens! Don’t let your soul be filled with evil!”.
And as the last breathe carried out those words, I awoke in the
forest, confused but rational. I wasn’t sure if this ordeal was a
dream or not but I knew I had to make my way back to town. Walking
through the streets I saw the faces of all the people who were just
moments ago preaching the work of Satan. I passed them by in disgust
as they carried on as if clueless to their wretched ways. My faith
was home, but I no longer saw her as my loving wife, for her innocence
was tainted with the same darkness as the shadows in the forest. The
night I left my Faith at home changed my life forever. I could never
again look at the people of Salem as I once saw them. I only saw the
evil that consumed them. Even if they chose not to reveal it, I still
knew.
Although the narration used by the author in “Young Goodman Brown”
creates a perfect environment for the plot there is still something
missing when it comes to the characters. The lack of first-person
narrative leaves the reader scratching their head during the moments
of suspense. Retelling the story from a first person perspective
helps depict what was going through Goodman Brown’s head during his
ordeal. The author’s focused on using a omniscient narrator to convey
the darkness, resentment, and regret that filled Goodman throughout
the story, while the retelling using the first-person narrative
focuses on a more indepth look of the character and his surrounding
world.
The omniscient narration gives great focus of the environment and
characters through imagery. The story begins with the author
describing Goodman as he begins his trip, “Goodman Brown came forth at
sunset, into the street of Salem Village, but put his head back, after
crossing the threshold, to exchange a parting kiss with his young
wife.” From the start of the conversation between Goodman Brown and
his wife the narration depicts the mood in the room by describing the
movement of the characters and the reactions they have toward each
other. He said, “‘Dearest heart,’ whispered she, softly and rather
sadly, when her lips were close to his ear”. Compared to the
retelling of the story, the first-person narrative avoids the scenic
route by stating how things really are from the perspective of the
character present in the room, “‘Dearest heart,’ She whispered to me
as she pleaded for me to stay. She didn’t want me to go, she was too
afraid for my safety, and for her own, as well. She exclaimed she was
too fearful of spending the night alone but I urged her to remain
hopeful and to trust in my words.”
Mid story, as Goodman Brown meets with the traveler, the role of the
omniscient narration is worked in in a masterful way. “It was now
deep dusk in the forest, and deepest in that part of it where those
two were journeying.” wrote Nathaniel Hathorne, the author of the
short story, in his attempt to use imagery as the main player in this
story. As previously mentioned, “darkness” and “resentment” play a
big part in the narration. Throughout the story Goodman Brown is
given signs that urge him to abandon his journey. The author goes on
to describe the fellow traveler’s walking staff, “But the only thing
bout him, that could be fixed upon as remarkable, was his staff, which
bore the likeness of a great black snake, so curiously wrought, that
it might almost be seen to twist and wriggle itself like a living
serpent. This, of course, must have been an ocular deception,
assisted by uncertain light. “A Good Man”, the retold version of this
short story, goes into detail about the traveler’s walking staff as
well but with minor focus on creating a mood based around the cane.
Goodman described the walking staff as he saw it, “Although he seemed
confidant and controlled, the staff that accompanied him was an
uncomfortable sight. A twisted walking stick that had a pattern to it
that resembled a serpent. With every step we made I could feel his it
slither beside us.” With this change of narration we’re able to
understand directly how Goodman Brown felt about the traveler and the
staff he kept on his person.
The use of the first-person narration is most beneficial during the
ending of the short story. When Goodman Brown becomes filled with
hate and resentment toward his fellow townspeople, he searches inside
himself for answers but is unable to rationalize the events that took
place. In a last hope of salvation, he closes off to the world and
becomes completely submerged in his purity, denying everyone who he
once knew any access to his innocence. The retold story ends with
this narration from Goodman Brown; “I could never again look at the
people of Salem as I once saw them. I only saw the evil that consumed
them. Even if they chose not to reveal it, I still knew.”. When we
compare this ending with that of the original short story we are able
to see how well the contrast in narration affects story, “And when he
had lived long, and was borne to his grave, a hoary corpse, followed
by Faith, an aged woman, and children and grand-children, a goodly
procession, besides neighbors, not a few, they carved no hopeful verse
upon his tombstone; for his dying hour was gloom.”
There are many advantages to each style of narration, the omniscient
narrator can submerge the reader in the world surrounding the
character while the first-person narrator is able to give us an inside
look through the eyes and heart of the protagonist. There is no wrong
way to narrate a story. It’s the author job to carry the readers from
the beginning to the end in a smooth and consistent manner, regardless
of the narrative style.