Approaching Criticism
— Emerson — we read to start our own teams
Do Androids Dream
— Human/Machine –
Human
living, organic, flesh and blood, feelings, irrational, conscience, compassionate, skilled, spontaneous, greedy, reproductive, self-healing/repairing
Machine
fabricated, artificial, cold, indifferent, mechanical, logical, rational, dispassionate, binary, slaves, predictable, calculated, man-made, assembled
compare moments when a robot “dies” in Androids
— these moments might show us something interesting about how the novel portrays robot sentience, human relationships to robots, and the blurred lines between humans and robots
choose a theme or repeated element to explore — ie., moments when a robot is shot in Androids — and we assemble the evidence — get all of those moments together in front of us, and then compare them
notice similarities and differences
— look at whole scene — person pulling trigger, too
speculate on why you think that is so and what the differences and similarities mean
cf. androids from CS to Androids
why in both books are there new, advanced robotic models —
as robots become more advanced they will effect our society’
1. Moments where androids are killed
2. Moments where the Voigt-Kampf test is administered
3. Moments that involve animals
4. Moments involving Mercer/Mercerism
5. Moments where people question their own identity
6. Moments of interaction (or discussions of interaction) between human males and android females
7. Moments in which the main character reflects and becomes merciful
8. Moments where we see physical structures crumbling (kipple)
9. Moments where we see the effects of dust
10. Moments where we see the importance of the TV show/radio
11. Moments where sleep/rest is discussed
Group 1
compared moments when robots die in Androids
as each android died — more graphic — new coming —