Author Archives: Ed

“Mother Tongue” response- Edmundo Ortega

Observations:

I noticed that the whole story is based on Amy’s mother English. I assume that’s the reason of the title “Mother Tongue” which is not complete but gives us an idea what she is trying to say.

Amy tan used metaphor for example “Language is the tool of my trade” she meant that English is fundamental in his profession.

She also used irony: “impeccable broken English” how something that is not complete can be impeccable?

She used her mother as an example to point out why there are not so many Asian American writers.

Amy described her mother’s English as a broken language, because her mother could not speak complete sentences in English.

She has memories about her mother limited English. She gave many examples of the way her mother express herself.

She remembers when she had to help her mother to communicate with others.

Amy’s strategy to write was pretending she was writing for her mother, so she could express herself better and makes it easier for the reader.

Amy remarked that she was embarrassed of her mother’s English.

Amy’s backgrounds are Chinese.

I felt compelling when Amy Tan said that when she was a teenager used to help her mother with the phone calls. Also because she described her mother as a limited English speaker, in my case would be my father. His English is way complicated than mine to understand, and most of the times he asks me to do phone calls in order to find out information for the checks and the working days.

My question about the text is the following; how is her mother’s English now days?

She wrote this book because she had been questioned about why others Asian-American are not involved into American literature. The author used her personal experience with her mother and used her as an example. She explains that her mother is able to understand perfect English but not to transmit her feeling and exact questions or arguments in English speech.  I think her purpose was to remark the importance of speech expression in order to communicate with others, also to motivate immigrant families to learn the English language.

“I Have a Dream” response- Edmundo Ortega

I noticed that in the announcement “I have a Dream” the author expressed himself, by an indirect way. He does not tell us the way he is feeling but he implies it. He is constantly remarking the discrimination to Negros and that government has not done anything to change that fact. He says that American Government has fail all the promises to the Negro community, I can tell that he felt upset at the current situation. Also that he was desperate for a change in the American Constitution towards Negros, looking for completely equality among African-American and white people. The author uses a lot of metaphor, for example; in the first sentence of the first paragraph when he says “In a sense we have come to our nation’s capital to cash a check” he did not meant cashing a check, he meant accomplishing the promises that were made to Negros hundred years ago by the government and still have not done it. Explained that there are some white people that does not discriminate them and supports their actions, meaning why government white people did not had the same point of view. Firmly said there will be no rest neither peace till the day they accomplished their goal, meaning they were fools.

I felt compelling to this announcement in the way that as an immigrant I’ve been discriminate by my original race. Also in the way when people makes promises to me and never accomplished them.

Why the author used a lot of metaphor in his announcement instead of saying it directly?

I think the author’s purpose by writing the announcement “I have a Dream” it was to remark the current situation that Negros were going through at 1963. They were being segregated of other American Citizens in the country and discriminated. I think he wrote it to claim government those equality rights and made it public to pressure government.