M.R. James Critical Response Prompts

Critical responses for this week will involve your answers to any of the following questions. As usual, please decide amongst yourselves who will write which prompts, and try to select a different prompt from one you’ve done already.

Questions for your annotated “investigation”:

Who is John Austin?

What is the significance of the wood that was used to carve the stalls in the Cathedral? What role does it play in the story’s events?
What took place at the “Hanging Oak”?
How is Haynes described in the opening obituary? Are there details in the story that undermine or contradict this description?
What is the significance of the letter found “in a letter in the pocket of the diary”?
What is the significance of one of the visual details found in the archdeacon’s stall? 
Why do Haynes’ fortunes worsen only after “three years of hard and careful work”?
Why does the obituary writer blame Voltaire, Byron, and Shelley for Haynes’ death?

 

CLUE.

Pick one answer to one of the above questions. How might it provide a clue as to the metaphorical significance of the titular cathedral? Think about the different churches and abbeys that have popped up in our readings and the sorts of meanings attached to them. Try to unpack how the plot detail you’ve chosen casts the cathedral in a new light.

CONNECT

Pick one answer to one of the above questions. Connect it to a claim that Andrew Smith makes in his essay on M.R. James and Gothic revival. How might this plot detail exemplify, parallel, or contrast with Smith’s observations about James’ other stories?

CREATE

Imagine you are a modern tourist taking a trip to Barchester cathedral, still standing in 2019. You enter and are granted access to the archdeacon’s stall. Describe your experience. What do you see? Are you tempted to touch what you see, and why? How do you feel in that space?

In 1-2 sentences after, explain the basis for your paragraph.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *