I do believe that Capa’s photograph was staged because there is no evidence of blood in the soldier’s shirt, for me it looks very dramatic, perfectly posed. First of all, I have a huge respect for war photographers, they are very brave to risk their lives to capture the horrors of war. I also acknowledge that in the mid 1930s, cameras were still manual, and that in order to take shots like the “falling soldier” one, the photographer should of had pre-set the camera to the right settings, to capture the movement of an object. The whole scene is on focus, it is as if Capa was in the right place at the right moment. The photograph is powerful indeed, but in my personal opinion I think that staging a photograph loses the whole sentiment of it, especially in situations like in the war, because there is a difference between art photography and journalist photography. Isn’t journalist photography to capture the raw reality, to tell the truth about events? I think its authenticity matters because, a photograph is a frame of time capture in paper, so the fact that it was fake, makes me doubt the reality.
Contact Information
Professor Sandra Cheng
Office: Namm 602B
Office Hours: Tu/Th 9-10 am or
by appointment
Office Tel: 718-260-5003
Email: scheng@citytech.cuny.eduHelpful Links
New York Times Arts
- The Tangs, New Donor Royalty, Step Into the Spotlight
- The Africa Center’s New Leader Focuses on Connection
- Kobe Bryant Still Reigns Over Los Angeles on Hundreds of Murals
- 5 Paths Through the Winter Show, an Exhibition of Earthly Delights
- Japan Once Dominated the Art Market. Is the Country Ready for a Comeback?
Blogroll
-
Recent Posts
- Re: Photographing the Beginning of the Civil Rights Movement
- Re:Discussion Topic: Street Art, Photography, and the Inside Out Project in Times Square
- Re: Tim Hetherington and Modern-day War Photography
- Response to: Tim Hetherington and Modern-day War Photography
- Photographing the Beginning of the Civil Rights Movement
Recent Comments
- Michael Lorenzo on Discussion Topic: Street Art, Photography, and the Inside Out Project in Times Square
- Michael Lorenzo on Discussion Topic: Tim Hetherington and Modern-day War Photography
- Michael Lorenzo on Discussion Topic: The Greatest War Photograph and Robert Capa
- Phalenta Pamphile on Discussion Topic: Street Art, Photography, and the Inside Out Project in Times Square
- Shantel on Discussion Topic: Photographing the Beginning of the Civil Rights Movement
Archives
Categories
Meta