Monthly Archives: December 2016
HW#3- Lauren Woods
I do find Richard’s argument to be very convincing. Though, I first thought that the photo was staged, I came to the conclusion the photo is not. Capa caught the bullet hitting the body of the downed solider, right as … Continue reading
HW #3: Death of a Loyalist Soldier
Robert Capa took photos from the GI landing on D-Day, at the risk of his own life. I personally do not find Whelan’s argument convincing for simple reasons. The fact that Capa put his life on the line for photos … Continue reading
HW#3: Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
From Robert Whelan’s analysis of Robert Capa and his works, he did very good job to concluded every detail information about the photograph “Death of a Loyalist Solider”. All these arguments and detail evidences did convince me, and the photo … Continue reading
Capa Controversy: A Photograph’s Dilemma by Yarie Vazquez
It only takes one picture. One picture can make the whole world question your authenticity. This may not be true for most of us, but it was and continues to be a question Robert Capa endured(s) before and after his … Continue reading
Ceyda Yildiz Homework #3 Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
I think Robert Whelan’s argument is very convincing. He explains everything in detail to prove that this infamous photograph by Capa was not staged. I think this picture is not staged , even though at first when i saw this … Continue reading
Death of a Loyalist Soldier
After reading the article “In Love and War” by Robert Whelan I’m still not convinced Robert Capa’s photo is fake. This is because nothing solid is being said to make the work unauthentic. Also in this case I don’t think … Continue reading
Kyomi Davis-Parker H.W #3
Richard Whelan’s arguments are extremely compelling because there’s no clear evidence that Robert Capa’s photograph was fake. Based on Whelan’s article and common knowledge of Capa’s photograph, I think the death of this soldier was real. The body position and … Continue reading
HW #3: Death of a Loyalist Soldier
Having learned about multiple famous photographs that turned out to have been altered or faked puts me in a rather dubious state of mind when determining the legitimacy of Capa’s “Death of a Loyalist Soldier.” Alas, I am still on … Continue reading
