Part 1 MLA citation:
Berliner, Wendy. âSchools Are Killing Curiosityâ: Why We Need to Stop Telling Children to Shut up and Learn.â The Guardian, The Guardian, 28 Jan. 2020, www.theguardian.com/education/2020/jan/28/schools-killing-curiosity-learn
Part 2 Summary:
In the article âSchools Are Killing Curiosity,â Wendy Berliner discusses how schools discourage children’s curiosity. Berliner cites a research study by Susan Engel, the author of âThe Hungry Mind.â Engel also actively researches children’s curiosity. In Engel’s research, she visited classrooms and logged the classroom questions. Engel noticed that the youngest children in the school asked two to five questions in two hours. While the 10-11 year olds who failed to ask a single question. In another lesson, she observed a ninth-grader trying to ask a question but was shot down by her teacher. âZoe no questions now, please; itâs time for learning.â This scene in Engelâs research study supports Berlinerâs claim that âSchools Are Killing Curiosityâ. Berliner uses another real-life example where a nursery took away its toys and gave the kids cardboard boxes, tin cans, old phones, etc. The nursery did this to encourage curiosity in the children and to allow the children to be more creative. The headteacher âMatt Cadwellâ claimed that many teachers were nonbelievers in this experiment but they later came around after seeing the improvements in the children’s curiosity and creativity. Berliner uses this nursery example to show that teachers should make better changes in the classroom to increase childrenâs curiosity.
Part 3 Rhetorical Analysis:
The genre is feature article. This is a very opinionated piece that informs the reader about the subject. Wendy Berliner’s writing style is informative. Berliner uses the rhetorical appeal of logos throughout the text citing research and using the research to further inform the reader about the subject. Berlinerâs purpose in writing this piece is to inform the reader how schools are discouraging childrenâs curiosity. Berliner’s primary audience for this article is parents. Berliner wants the reader to understand how schools are ruining childrenâs curiosity. Berliner is credible due to her being the author of the book âHow to Succeed at School, What Every Parent Should Knowâ. The source is also, credible itâs published by âThe Guardianâ. The Guardian has been a successful news source since 1821.
Part 4 Notable Quotes:
âSchool kills curiosity. When do children get to ask questions about things that interest them? As soon as they are at primary school they have to shut up and learn. Itâs not the fault of teachers. They have so many targets to meet.â (Wendy Berliner)
âChildren should be prompted and encouraged to ask questions even though that can be challenging for the teacher,â he says. âWe do need to find some time for questions during the day. There is not enough time in schools for creativity and following up on curiosity.â (Paul Howard-Jones)
Ok – Good!
In Rhet ANalysis: I would not say this is opinionated. It’s presenting evidence that shows she has a slant, but the writing is NOT opinionated. When we take a look at opinion articles you will see the difference.