In the book “The Color Purple”, written by Alice Walker, she differentiates the characters, Celie and Sofia. Even though they are both Black women who are experiencing similar issues, the two characters holds an identity of their own. In the past Celie and Sofia have both experienced a tuff coming of age, due to their families. Unfortunately, their struggles/issues is never brought to a stop. Being the adults they are now today, Celie and Sofie continuously experience struggles living in their very own household. The two women are now married living along Albertâs property. Albert is Celie’s husband, and Albertâs son is the husband of Sofias. However, like most people would claim to say “father like son” Albert and Harpo (his son) both beat their wives. This is an issue of domestic violence. Readers are able to get a sense of the different characteristics the two characters present when dealing with domestic violence.
Celie who is much older than Sofia has suffered through many hardship experiences throughout her life, as stated above. Her mother died from illness, she is a victim of rape, her babies were taken from her, she lost the right to stay in school, and her step children treat her very poorly. In the book Celie is having a conversation with her younger sister Nettie, Nettie says, âYou got to let them know who got the upper hand. They got it, I say. But she keep on, You got to fight. You got to fight. But I donât know how to fight. All I know how to do is stay alive.â (Pdf. Pg. 19) Celie states she does not know how to fight and that the only thing she knows how to do is stay alive. This allows the readers to get a sense of her mindset and how she lets the pain and sorrow take over her whole life. She feels her battle with the children is not worth sacrificing her loneliness and continues to obey Albertâs children. Not only does Celie obeys Albertâs children she also lets him beat on her. In the book Celie recalls the reaction of Sofia when she notices that she is scared of Albert. It states âI think bout how every time I jump when Mr. _____ call me, she look surprise.â (Pdf. Pg. 29) This gives me an insight of how the two characters are different from one another. Another statement from the book that exemplifies Celies type of character is when she stated, âI like Sofia, but she donât act like me at all. If she talking when Harpo and Mr. _____ come in the room, she keep right on. If they ast her where something at, she say she donât know. Keep talking.â (Pdf. Pg. 29) This gives readers an understanding that if this was Celie who was talking when Harpo came in the room she would shut-up, and if someone was to ask her where something is she wouldâve gotten up to find it. Celie has no voice and has never fought back, she allows people to walk all over her and boss her around. Even the people who surrounds her sympathy her, such as Nettie, her husbandâs sisters, Sofie, and Shurag.
Now Sofia has also encountered through a ruff past herself, as stated. However, she is a strong women who fights back and doesnât let the pain and sorrow take over her life. She has fallen in love with Harpo and he creates a little shack for her and the baby to live in, right on his fatherâs property. Harpo loves Sofia but when he takes advice from his father and Celie on how to keep her, the violence occurs. Celie advises Harpo to beat Sofia because she is jealous of her bravery towards others. In the book it states âNext time us see Harpo his face a mess of bruises. His lip cut. One of his eyes shut like a fist. He walk stiff and say his teef ache.â (Pdf. Pg. 29) This gives me an interpretation of what happened that night when Harpo tried to beat Sofia for the first time. She had fought back and beaten him up herself. Sofia states âAll my life I had to fight. I had to fight my daddy. I had to fight my brothers. I had to fight my cousins and my uncles. A girl child ainât safe in a family of men. But I never thought Iâd have to fight in my own house. She let out her breath. I loves Harpo, she say. God knows I do. But Iâll kill him dead before I let him beat me. Now if you want a dead sonin-law you just keep on advising him like you doing. She put her hand on her hip.â (Pdf. Pg. 31) Sofia is furious and she lets Celie know that she will kill Harpo if she has to. The hand on her hip symbolizes the bad-ass woman she is. From this day forward Celie starts to respect Sofia, however, she does not have the courage to actually become her.
I like how you explain the similarities and difference between Celie and Sofia regarding their upbringing and they way they handled their situations differently. It is very true that Sofia is a fighter while any fight Celie might have had in her was beat out of her.
Sofia obviously benefited from having other siblings who would ally with her when her other brothers wanted to fight. She also mentioned that at least one of the brothers sided with the sisters. This is not to say the Celie was not a strong person but it is also obvious that Sofia was physically imposing and as strong as most men. This no doubt helped her when she decided to defend herself. That all being said, Celie had the misfortune of being raised by an abusive stepdad. Even so it is obvious that Celie had a different approach to violence and was not comfortable with expressing her aggressiveness or being dominant. She was very empathetic, remarking that even when he spank her younger siblings it was not even hard enough for them to really be bothered by it.
You made an interesting comparison between Celie and Sofia. They both had their difference at the beginning but later on the understood each other and learned how to be comfortable with one another. You made the statement Celie started to respect Sofia but didn’t actually become her. I don’t think Celie could ever have enough to become Sofia. No matter how much closer she gets towards becoming like her. Celie had experiences that shook her, and I believe people rarely come out to be as strong as they can be after being a rape victim and Celie had it way worse, it was her father figure who did and on top of that she was raised not to talk to anyone. Over all I really like what you wrote.
Celie and Sofia’s relationship was not the best early on due to the difference in characters. Sofia was a stronger character than Celie especially against Harpo and that makes Celie envious. I agree that why she advises Harpo to beat her. Celie has only encoutered violence so she believes violence is a logical. But, Sofia’ attitude towards domestic violence and her strong aggressive shows the difference in how both their past affects their future attitude
“Celie has only encoutered violence so she believes violence is a logical” Good point, Dinesh!
Nice comparison, Suchi!