Author: Steven Ng

Final Essay Outline

Introduction

  1. The establishment of ethics
    1. Will be primarily focused on Deontology and Virtue ethics
  2. The introduction of A Good Fall by Ha Jin
    1. The characters that will be focused on are Ganchin, Cindy and the restaurant owner
  3. Thesis as to how Deontology and Virtue ethics applies to these characters

Body Paragraph One

1) Summary of A Good Fall

2) Focused on Ganchin, since he is the main protagonist

  1. Ganchin is a monk who changes towards the end of the story
    1. Deontology, in Ganchin’s case, should be focused on his monk traditions
      1. When Ganchin is offered food by the restaurant owner, the owner apologizes to Ganchin by stating that he forgot that he was a monk and should have given him vegetarian food. Ganchin responses that he can eat seafood.
      2. When Ganchin wanted to commit suicide, Master Zong responds, “Don’t talk about death. We monks must cherish every life. Life is given us only once, and it’s a sin to destroy it”. Ganchin goes on to attempt to commit suicide, only to break his leg and getting Master Zong exposed to the public.
      3. When Ganchin was with Cindy towards the beginning of the story, she mentioned that he should marry a female U.S citizen, in which he retorts that he was a monk and cannot “think of anything like that”. Towards the end of the story, he reconsiders this.

Body Paragraph Two

  1. Focused on Cindy and the restaurant owner
    1. How their Virtue ethics shine through
      1. Cindy seems to want to help Ganchin without any repayment because she seems to be infatuated with him. She goes to even hire a lawyer for him to fight Master Zong for the unpaid salary.
      2. Before the attempted suicide, the restaurant owner offers Ganchin advice and a free meal. Despite his relative lack of impact, when compared to Cindy, it felt like a turning point. Ganchin was in his most depressed state in that point in the story, where he had no home to return to and was on the run from Master Zong, and the owner was like that single trickle of light.

Conclusion

  1. The restatement of the thesis.
  2. Closing statement.

Midterm Essay Outline

Introduction

  1. The establishment of the gothic fiction, perhaps providing a short definition and example in about two sentences.
  2. The introduction of at least two stories.
    1. The Lottery by Shirley Jackson.
    1. Young Goodman Brown by Nathaniel Hawthorne.
    1. An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge by Ambrose Bierce.
  3. Thesis as to how gothic fictions apply to the above-mentioned works of fiction.
    1. Notably how all these stories have a historical background and that their characters experience some short of change.

Body Paragraph One

  1. A relatively brief summary of The Lottery.
  2. Focus on how gothic fiction is related to Tessie Hutchinson.
    1. How she approves of the lottery in the beginning of the story.
    1. How she changes over time when she finds out that her family is chosen.
    1. Her ultimate, untimely end towards the end of the story.

Body Paragraph Two

  1. A relatively brief summary of Young Goodman Brown.
  2. Focus on how gothic fiction is related to Goodman Brown.
    1. How he is a devout Christian that believes everyone else is just like him, based on what he has seen on the ‘surface’.
    1. How he changes to grow to distrust everyone else towards the end of the story.

Body Paragraph Three

  1. A relatively brief summary of An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge.
  2. Focus on how gothic fiction is related to Peyton Farquhar.
    1. How he is living ‘normally’ in the South.
    1. How his ending takes an unexpected turn for the worse.

Body Paragraph Four/Five

  1. The comparison of the similarity of Tessie Hutchinson and Peyton Farquhar.
  2. The difference of Goodman Brown, in relation to the above two characters.

Conclusion

  1. The restatement of the thesis.
    1. How these characters do indeed prove the thesis.
  2. Add a closing statement.

Coffee House #4

The Enormous Radio by John Cheever reminds me of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Young Goodman Brown in that everything seemed quite ‘normal’ in the beginning when the characters are introduced. It quickly goes downhill from there once Jim Westcott and his wife, Irene, acquires a radio to replace the one that became broken. Like how Goodman Brown goes on a journey into a dark forest and meets people that he thought he knew, Irene notices that the strange ugly radio was able to receive their neighbors’ sounds and the surrounding apartment complex. The shock of being able to listen to elevator, doorbells and even to the apartment next to their apartment led to an increased fascination of the radio. So much so that Irene purposely cuts her time short with her friends just to go back home and listen to the radio, as if overly addicted. She does transform to become a person who never leaves the house and invents a new goal in life, which is to only listen to the radio. By doing so, Irene changes her perspective of everything around her, including her husband, due to the influence of said radio. The Enormous Radio is a gothic story because it shares traits with Young Goodman Brown that involves a character changing what they consider to be their normality into a completely different one. In addition, the new radio that the Westcott’s purchased was rather strange and foreshadows the darkness that resulted in Irene’s and Jim’s marriage becoming conflicted at the conclusion of the story.

The only way I believe that The Enormous Radio would not be a gothic literature is if the story progresses like how it normally is, up until the point where instead of Irene becoming obsessed with the new radio, she would either dispose of it or attempt to stop crime as if she was trying to be like Batman. This is because the new, ugly radio functioned like what the modern American Federal Bureau of Investigation did after the deadly events of September 11th, 2001. The agency actually spied on the American population for fear of another terrorist attack. Many New Yorkers were also encouraged to report strange actions done in the MTA subway system, with many “If you see something, say something” advertisement posted all over MTA property.

Coffeehouse #3

The five most important ideas from Alan Lloyd-Smith’s “American Gothic”, in my opinion, are:

  1. Substitution (Middle of Page 4)
  2. Influences that real life circumstances are based off of (Middle of Page 4)
  3. Human struggles used in popular media (Bottom of Page 4 to Top of Page 5)
  4. “Good versus Evil” (Bottom of Page 5 to Top of Page 6)
  5. Science and the Supernatural (Middle of Page 6)

Coffee House #2

Out of the six stories listed, the one story that catches my fascination is “The Captive”, by Jose Luis Borges. This is a short story that has its framework established with a beginning and some sort of conclusion to its tale. Part of my fascination for this story stems from my interest in its historical roots, in that it is set sometime during the colonization periods between the 1500s and 1800s in the time of the Age of Exploration. However, what really intrigued me the most is the mysterious circumstances that ‘the boy’ has experienced between the point of his kidnap to his fateful reunion with his parents. It forces us, the reader, to question or maybe even attempt to brainstorm what transpire such a change, which resulted in him losing his native tongue and having a toughened body. One possible idea may be that the boy managed to escape from his captors but could not return to his village because he was not familiar with his current surroundings. Perhaps, the boy may even have traveled to the ‘old world’ without the readers ever knowing since the story never stated time frames before and after the time lapse. Maybe, in order to survive, he had to adapt and learn the European language, which is why we witness his confusion towards the end of the short story. It is these uncertainties that piques my interest into this short story that, if I were ever given the chance to, would greatly expand upon Mr. Borge’s story. And despite giving us a minuscule amount of information regarding the boy’s transformation, “The Captive” reminds me of a story that goes by the name of “The Hatchet”, by Gary Paulsen. Admittedly, I have not read “The Hatchet” in a long time, but it somehow gives off the same vibes as “The Captive”, in that if the short story is lengthened, it can be about the boy’s initial struggles, survival and his eventual change.

For reference, “The Hatchet” is also about a young boy who was forced to learn how to survive in the modern Canadian forest by himself after his pilot suffers a heart attack en route to the young boy’s destination on a small plane. Brian, the story’s protagonist, improvises his forest home, adapts to his situation, and overcomes hardships with the use of his trusty hatchet. At the end of “The Hatchet”, Brian gets rescued and returns to society as a changed man that had survived in the forest for fifty-two days. Unlike “The Captive”, the reader knows the exact details of Brian’s hardships and struggles that he was forced to endure as soon as his plane had crash landed. Be that as it may, “The Captive” carries unlimited potential of storytelling that the reader can conjure up in order to fill the missing gap that Mr. Borge has left us between the boy’s abduction and his homecoming.