Homework Assignment 1, due Monday 2/26

Read the article, “Medical learning curves and the Kantian ideal” (Le Morvan and Stock, link in syllabus) and answer the following questions concisely. Please use your own words. (Of course, if you do use the words of the authors, you must use quotation marks. But please try to use your own words).

  1. What is the thesis of this piece? 
  2. Briefly explain two major arguments the authors use to support their thesis. 

Your answer should be at least half a page but no more than one page (handwritten or typed and double spaced), or about 150-300 words. Please bring a hard copy of the assignment to class.

Reading Questions Instructions

You will be able to see new reading questions for each week on the Reading Questions page. The purpose of the reading questions is to give you a clue about what to look for when doing the readings, and to encourage you to read for comprehension rather than mere completion. 

The reading questions will appear on the exam study sheet, and so they (or some form of these questions) may also appear on exams. We will discuss the answers to the first pair in class this week, but after that we will not directly address the answers either in class or in our review sessions. So be sure to answer them! Although we won’t cover them directly in class, feel free to work with classmates to identify answers. 

Readings Due 2/22

For links to readings, see Course Schedule and Readings. Please note, you do NOT need to answer these here. Answer them for yourself as you read and save the answers–you will need them for the exams!

According to Kant, how do we typically justify to ourselves actions that are against duty?

According to McCormick, what must we do when different prima facie binding principles (like respect for autonomy, beneficence, etc) conflict with each other?

Reminder: No Class Tonight!

This is a reminder that there are no classes at City Tech today. Our class is also canceled for tonight. 

Next Monday is also a holiday, and there are no classes that day either. Our next meeting will be Thursday, 2/22 at 6pm. Classes that day will run on a Monday schedule. As always, you can see our schedule for this class if you have any questions. 

See you on 2/22!

Dr. M

Welcome!

I’m Dr. MacDougall, your professor for Health Care Ethics (PHIL 2203). There are two things I want you to know before our first meeting on January 29.

1. Most of our written interactions, class updates and materials, are available on our OpenLab site. Please join our OpenLab section as soon as possible. You will be required to join in order to participate in online discussions. You can also see the schedule and assignments there.

2. This class is an Open Educational Resource (OER) course. That means there is no textbook, and all readings are freely available online. This saves you money and means you can store all our readings on your hard drive, indefinitely! You can find links to class readings on the schedule page.

Let me know if you have any questions. I’m looking forward to meeting you.

Dr. MacDougall