The Authors’ Attitude on the Indigenous People

Each author depicts the indigenous people in their own way through each individual story. As we see in “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne,  we see the view and the attitude towards the indigenous people is shown by the dialogue of the old man describing how he helped Goodman Brown’s father set ablaze upon an Indian village. The author shows how he does not care much for the indigenous people since he does not tell or show much else of them either then the fire set on their town. We get no reaction or dialogue in regards to them as well. This can show that the author does not show some sort of sympathy even by the use of Goodman Brown in little to no reaction to the people but rather is more concerned with his father betraying his faith. Hemingway depicts the indigenous people different in his story compared to Hawthorne. Hemingway depicts them is his story “Indian Camp” not much of the indigenous people except that they are obedient to the doctor trying to help a fellow indigenous woman give birth. They do not speak much nor do they show much emotion throughout the story. I feel as if the author uses the indigenous people just to carry out the story till the end then show much care about them in the first place. In addition, even though the indigenous people are the reason for the doctor traveling to their village to help the woman in labor with his son, Nick, and his fellow friend George, they are not even the center of the story. The story mostly revolves around our three outsiders previously mentioned. Another example of Hemingway not showing much care or emotion towards the indigenous people would be when the doctor and his son react towards the dead body of the indigenous man who committed suicide as he is laying in a pool of his own blood. Their reaction was not as shocking as one may be when they come across a body of someone who committed suicide especially Nick since he is still young.

HW + Blog instructions for 9/26 (Hemingway)

Dear class,

Thanks for your work this week! As we look ahead, note two things on the horizon: 1) we’re moving into the 20th century next week, and 2) your Essay 1 deadline is approaching in early October.  I recommend spending at least 1 hour on starting the essay this weekend.

For the other 2 hours of prep time, read the Hemingway stories, blog (group 6) or comment, and review your class notes.  Instead of reading questions this time, I’m asking you to generate your own, based on the first few sentences of “Indian Camp”:

At the lake there was another rowboat drawn. The two Indians stood waiting.  Nick and his father got in the stern of the boat and the Indians shoved the camp boat off and got in to row Uncle George.

Write down some questions that these sentences raise, either about what happens in the rest of the story (e.g. the development of plot, setting, characters), or about Hemingway’s interests as a writer.  (Think about whether these sentences suggest thematic interests, or a particular style.)  Be prepared to discuss these questions at the beginning of class.  We will use this passage to discuss how to structure your analysis.

Blog instructions for Group 6:

  1. Connect: Without giving too much away, “Indian Camp” involves representations of Native American characters.  compare “Indian Camp” to another story from the syllabus that features Native Americans, “Young Goodman Brown.”  What kind of attitude does each author take toward America’s historical treatment of indigenous peoples?  (Do they care?)

2. Create: imagine you’re Nick as a young adult, and you’ve just read either one of our Stephen Crane stories or one of the Kate Chopin stories.  Write a letter to your dad about how the story you’ve just read (“Story of an Hour”? “Men In The Storm”?) might you of what happened “that day at Indian camp.”  Don’t just refer to events, but to your emotions on that day.  Use quotations. As always with Create, include a brief explanation at the end.  The point here is to reflect on how Nick might resemble characters/personalities from the Crane or Chopin stories.

3. Clue: pick two quotations (other than the first few lines of “Indian Camp”) and explain how they offer a window into Hemingway’s signature style.  Explain why you think Hemingway chooses to leave certain details out, and include others.

An Hour And The Bayou

“The Story Of An Hour” and “Beyond The Bayou” by Kate Chopin are both different from each other, but both are about a woman and they are the main characters in the story. The story of an hour is about a woman named Mrs. Mallard with heart disease. For some reason the writer showed us that her husband died in the beginning of the story to build a connecting with readers and the main character’s health situation. Since she was diagnosed with the heart disease, a lot of things were going around in her mind. When she locked herself in her room, she felt like something was talking to her. “She said it over and over under her breath: “free, free, free!””.(pg: 47). That shows she finally got her freedom and it tells us what kind of relationship she had with her husband. I tried to compare this story with one of the stories I’ve read in my other class called “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. I can find a similarity between these two stories. In “The Yellow Wallpaper” the main character used to talk to the wall and the writer mentioned that she saw something on the wall, like Mrs. Mallard was talking to herself. In the other hand “Beyond The Bayou” is about an independent woman, who works as hard as a man. Her name was Jacqueline but she was known as La Folle. She used to work hard every day. She made a friendship with the son of the owner of Bellissime named Cheri. He used to come to her all the time and tell her everything. I can compare this story to one of the story we’ve read in this class “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker. The main character or the mother used to work like La Folle all the time. She was a strong woman too. When I was comparing the two characters from “The Story Of An Hour” and “Beyond The Bayou”, I couldn’t find any similarity between two of them. Mrs. Mallard is kind of quiet person and La Folle is always friendly and outgoing.

The Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin and Beyond The Bayou by Kate Chopin

There are various similarities and differences between “The Story of an hour” and “Beyond The Bayou” in regards to feminism. Chopin depicts the struggles of female characters by characterizing them as being fragile. In The Story of an Hour Mrs. Mallard has a heart trouble and suddenly receives the horrifying news that her husband has been killed in an accident. Mrs. Mallard does not have a normal reaction. The fact that Mrs. Mallard has heart trouble it made her seem very weak. Why couldn’t it be vice versa with her husband. I felt that is was characterizing females as complicated. On page 47 it states ” She was beginning to recognize this thing that was approaching to possess her, and she was striving to beat it back with her will”, my educational guess is that Mrs. Mallard is approaching her death and some spirt has came for her. The news  about her husbands death affected her not at the moment but afterwards. In Beyond The Bayou the author characterized women of being equal to men. On page 50 it states ” She dwelt alone in her solitary cabin, for the rest of the quarters had long since been removed beyond her sight and knowledge. She had more physical strength than most men” this depicts the character as a strong independent women.                                                   In The story of an hour Mrs. Mallard does change but not voluntarily it seems that something has gotten into her and took control of her body and soul. The settings are very different from one another. The Story of the hour setting takes place in a home where a women finds out devastating news about what had occurred to her husband and she goes running to a room where she passes her last few moments alive. In Beyond The Bayou the setting takes place in a remote area where the people living on it work on it daily.

Beyond the Bayou

I chose to compare Rip Van Winkle’s wife and Jacqueline, or La Folle. Both of these female characters are polar opposites. Irving doesn’t give Rip’s wife a thorough introduction to her character. All we know is that she is always yelling at Rip on what to do and what he’s doing wrong. In Chopin’s story of Beyond the Bayou, La Folle is given to us in details from what she looks like and how she gotten her nickname. La Folle has more power to change the story the in whatever way she would have wanted, and she also conquered her fear of crossing the bayou. In Rip Van Winkle, Rip’s wife never had the chance to say much throughout the story, so she couldn’t have much influence on how the ending would end.