
2A In the past, I have used other creatives’ work in my own work for various COMD course projects. Such projects are usually centered designing content for already existing brands. A prime example would be my Care/of Social Media Advertisement project.
Care/of is an American healthcare technology company specializing in premium vitamins and supplements. Care/of’s aim is to simplify the consumer’s process of receiving their daily nutritional needs by formulating personalized vitamin packs and supplements based on information provided by the consumer via an online quiz. In addition, the vitamin packs and supplements are made more affordable than traditional means of purchase through Care/of’s subscription based business model.
The overall goal of this project was to bring more attention to Care/of as well as the company’s partnership with GOOD+ through a Mother’s Day/Women’s Health Month themed animated gif. The animated gif would be displayed via Care/of’s social media channels (specifically Instagram) as well as the company’s email newsletter, accompanied by additional text further expanding upon the mission of GOOD+. The development of this project included, brand research & exploration, storyboarding, vector art design, and basic frame-by-frame animation.
For the vector art design aspect of this project, I created a digital version of Care/of’s vitamin pouch packaging. In order to have my digital version of the packaging look as similar to Care/of’s actual packaging as possible, I had to utilized the company’s logo and color palette. Although creating a near identical digital version of Care/of’s packaging was paramount to the project’s success, it was important for me to keep in mind that I was essentially digitizing as physical piece of design created by another design whom I did not know. In order to satisfy the goals of my project and to avoid being accused of plagiarism, I made sure to state in my portfolio what parts of the project I designed. I also made sure to state that the project was completed as part of my communication design coursework.
– – –
CARE OF SOCIAL MEDIA ADVERTISEMENT

https://www.artic.edu/artworks/
2B I first heard of the Hope Poster case sometime during my sophomore or junior year of high school. I attended an arts high school as a visual art major, so the topic meshed well with the curriculum. During class, a question related to copyright was posed by a classmate of mine during the Pop Art unit of our art history curriculum which prompted my art teacher to give the class a brief rundown of the Shepard Fairey and the Hope Poster case. One major take away from my teacher’s explanation of the case that has stuck with me for years is the idea that if a piece you’ve created based on another artist’s work isn’t at least 60 percent different from that artist’s work, it’s plagiarism.Â
Later, sometime during the summer, I stumbled across graffiti artist Banksy’s 2010 documentary Exit Through the Gift Shop on television. I was fan of Banksy’s work, so I was immediately intrigued and decided to give the documentary a watch. Shepard Fairey was featured quite a bit in the documentary and I found myself learning more about his artwork and creative process. It was then that I realize that Shepard Fairey was the creative behind the infamous OBEY t-shirts that were extremely popular at the time. I found this to be an interesting tidbit of information since the OBEY t-shirt designs feature an icon of a man’s face directly based on a photograph of professional wrestler Andre the Giant. The creative process by which Fairey created the OBEY icon was nearly identical to that of the Obama Hope Poster.
After reading the excerpt from Harvard Journal of Law and Technology’s “Reflections on the Hope Poster Case” and learning that the Hope Poster case ended in a settlement, I’m still unsure of exactly what the courts could have or should have done to resolve the issue instead of settling the dispute. On one hand, I am a believer in the idea that those who plagiarize art should face penalties for their actions. However, on the other hand, if Shepard Fairey were to be punished, what would that mean for artists such as Richard Prince whose artworks tend to be heavily based on appropriation? After reviewing the image exhibits provided toward the end of the document, I personally take the stance that Shepard Fairey’s Obama Hope poster bares enough of a difference compared to the Obama Garcia photo for it to be considered its own piece of art free of copyright infringement.
– – –
RESOURCE:Â Case Study on Fair Use and Fair Dealing: The Hope Poster Litigation