In the article “Backpacks vs. Briefcases: Steps Towards Rhetorical Analysis” by Laura Bolin Caroll explains how rhetoric surrounds us as it is seen around the world in many different ways. Persuasion is what defines rhetoric. Caroll. In addition in the forth century, Aristotle educated the men of Athens on how to persuade audiences using different types of rhetorical situations. This lead to his three “artistic appeals”, which are logos, pathos, and ethos. Caroll also argues about the three parts to understanding the context of a rhetorical moment. Exigence, Audience, and Constraints. exigence is a response to a problem . The audience is whom respond to the exigence and the constraints have the power to take decisions and actions to modify the exigence.
Rhetorical situations happen in our everyday life and many people are not aware of that. The article clearly presents all points in a very clear and organized manner. I learned the word constrain, which is to compel or force someone to follow a particular course or action.
In this excerpt by Nelson Graff, it talks about the impact of rhetorical analysis, and the many ways it plays a role in our everyday life. Then they also started to talk about the impact it has on students. And that they believe that the information we are receiving in a generic English class. But it is not able to bring that knowledge into another classes that they are participating in. I believe that mainly because it talks about they teach us how to write, but not how to learn how to write. And that I had to think about what that meant but it makes sense. We get taught strategies, but we don’t get taught when to use them. There aren’t any scenarios which we could be given in which we can gain understanding. Which could be used to carry on to other subjects. And this might be a problem that might just take a bit longer to fix than students would hope.
In the excerpt “Backpacks vs. Briefcases” by Laura Carroll, she talks about the impact the rhetorical analysis has on people in their everyday lives. That we all analyze people after just meeting them. And in a few seconds we could have a very accurate analysis of who ever we were analyzing. Then ads are becoming increasingly more prevalent in our lives, and because of that it plays more of a inpact on our beliefs than if did when people were happier in the 50’s. She then goes on to show that there are complex and simple rhetorics, and for it to be rhetorical it has to be persuasive. Then she goes on to say that you can break it down from its purpose to its constraints to the actual persuasion, which made sense. It was used through the forms of pathos, logos, or ethos. What sells the persuasion is the pathos, but you will need ethos or logos to not make it too overbearing. Then there are other aspects as timing. When and where the ad takes place, who is the intended audience and second and third intended audience. And the people who know this are one of the most influential people in the world, simply because they can create change especially when something is creating a negative impact to the people it is advertised to. It was a lot to read but it made a lot of sense but it also gave a sense of hope to know that if you know how this all works you have the power and the ability to change it which in result makes the world a safer and more friendlier place.