Project 3 Completed

screenshotjuxtaposition.

 

 

 

 

To get here from City tech, you’ll have to leave the school from the Johnson st exit, then across the street and you’ll find yourself on Adams st, and quickly back on Johnson st. You then walk down a block on Johnson st and make a left turn and find yourself towards the west of Cadman Plaza, so you across the street, make a right, and make your way onto Pierrepont st. From there you walk 4 blocks down, and that’s when you’ll reach 70 Pierrepont st, where i took this picture.

This picture is a great example of Juxaposition because it shows two diffrent buildings next to each other. On the left side, you see an old type of brick design, and by looking at the building, you can tell it’s been around for quite some time. And on the right side, you see a more modern look type of building, with a newer look to it.

I did a little bit of research and found out that 70 Pierrepont street has history that dates all the way back to 1925, and is one of the most expensive places to live in Brooklyn to date. And it’s been said that great literary writing was started in Brooklyn Heights, and many of the great and influential writers such as Walt Whitman, was inspired by brooklyn, “Brooklyn Heights has been a writers’ paradise since the days of Walt Whitman in the 1840s. “He drew energy from Brooklyn,” reported Evan Hughes in “Literary Brooklyn.” Whitman worked at Rome Brothers, a print shop on Cranberry and Fulton streets where, in his off hours, he set type for a long, wild poem that would become “Leaves of Grass.” His daytime job as editor at 26 of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle lasted until he was fired for criticizing the publisher’s politics. Walt, an elementary school dropout, struggled to support his family. They led a peripatetic life moving in the Heights from Front Street to Henry to Adams to Tillary. In subsequent years, other writers followed Whitman’s pattern in Brooklyn Heights, often moving close to their peers. This literary history was recounted by John Gardiner in the Brooklyn Heights Press in 1983 in a review of the book, “Literary New York,” by Susan Edmiston and Linda Cirino. Gardiner wrote about anecdotal encounters with famous celebrities: Thomas Wolfe, Arthur Miller, Norman Mailer and Norman Rosten. These literary giants of yesteryear created an aura that prevailed in Brooklyn from the 1920s to this day.” Best said by writer John B. Manbeck….

https://brooklyneagle.com/articles/2019/08/06/writers-brooklyn-heights/

One article that supports my project is, “Here, Property And Priviege Are Neighbors; Income Gaps Are a Source Of Resentment and Guilt” by  Janny Scott, she state “The intricate geography of income difference in New York City is something Chastity Davis absorbed early, growing up in the 1980’s in a tenement apartment in Boerum Hill, Brooklyn, on a block of mostly brick row houses flanked by public housing projects at either end.” Also, “A defining characteristic of New York City is its economic diversity, the juxtaposition of people of disparate circumstances in limited space. The gap between top and bottom is greater in New York than in most cities in the country, and people at the extremes often live closer together.”

I agree with those statements because, New York may be a beautifully built city, but it is very hard to live in. New York is known as one of the most richest and sprawling cities in the U.S due to it’s economic success over the years, so living in New York comes with the certainty of going broke. So many people resort to living is less diverse neighborhoods, such as project housing, with bad living conditions. As shown in my photo above, there are two completely different buildings against each other. One looks so clean with a nice white stone design, presumably built just recently, or not too long ago rather, and the other building has a worn out brick design, presumably built a while ago, there’s nothing enticing about this building. Obviously, you can make an assumption that there’s some sort of economic difference between these buildings, people who live in the brick buildings don’t pay too much for living expenses, whereas the people who live in the white stone building pay a ton.

Project 3 Completed

 

To get there from city tech, you will have to have to take the R train at Jay Street- Metrotech station to Dekalb Avenue or Atlantic Avenue. Or you can take 20-25 minutes to walk straight from the Jay Street entrance to Fulton street and then walk west until you get to Flatbush Avenue where you will walk southwest for approximately 10 minutes. This is an example of Juxtaposition because some of the buildings in this area are more modern than the others. The Barclays Center is a perfect example of juxtaposition because it juxtaposes the modern shops and skyscrapers with the old and more affordable buildings.

Many neighborhoods in Brooklyn have changed a lot physically throughout recent years. This process, called gentrification is the reason why many neighborhoods look different today compared to what they looked like 10years ago. An area that has been heavily changed by gentrification is Downtown Brooklyn. The rezoning of many stores and the construction of the Barclays Center creates a strong juxtaposition with the modern shops and skyscrapers that surround the Barclays Center and the older, affordable buildings that still remain in the area. The Construction of the Barclay’s Center caused a lot of controversies, a lot of New Yorkers opposed the project. According to Business Insider, “Why Half Of Brooklyn Hates The New Barclay’s Center Stadium” by Joshua Berlinger, a Digital reporter, and producer for CNN, “The entire $4 billion project would use $1.6 billion funding.” This is one of the reasons why many residents were furious with the construction of the Barclays Center and still hold grudges against the City. Many people also argue that the project abused the power of eminent domain which gives the right to the government of the United States to expropriate private property for public use, with compensation often not being what the real value of the properties are.   

One article that supports my project is “Here, Poverty and Privilege Are Neighbors; Income Gaps Are A Source Of Resentment and Guilt BY Janny Scott. In the article, Jenny Scott states “The city  is etched with boundaries and borderlands that appear on no maps, areas where income groups intersect, overlap, collide, coexist– along lines drawn and redrawn by quirks on history, differences in housing stock, patterns of immigration and the economy’s perpetual rise and fall.” I agree with this statement because I feel like when people look at a city on a physical map or even digital map, they don’t see the beauty, diversity and everything else the city has to offer. Someone who does not live in New York City might look at the city on a map and they will not get the same feeling. Later on, in the same article, the author states, “ For some, the juxtaposition is a virtue, one of the city’s fascinations; for others, they are a source of resentment and guilt.” I also agree with this statement because I feel like gentrification can be viewed as a juxtaposition. For a lot of people, gentrification is a source of resentment and guilt because when new people move into a new neighborhood and gentrify it, most of the time the pricing in the area increases, making it hard for those who once lived there to pay bills and afford food. An area that has been drastically changed by gentrification is Downtown Brooklyn. Today, downtown Brooklyn looks more modern than how it looked like 10-20 years ago. Today, downtown Brooklyn looks more like lower Manhattan than the rest of Brooklyn. The construction of the Barclays Center caused a lot of rezoning. More stores relocated their business to downtown Brooklyn because the area became an attraction especially with the Brooklyn Nets basketball team moving from New Jersey to the Barclays Center in Brooklyn which caused the rent to increase in the area and caused many people to be displaced from their homes. The construction of the Barclays Center also increased the traffic in the area. Today, many new skyscrapers are being built in an area that no longer is affordable for many people. Another article that supports my project is “The Way We Live Now: 11-11-01; Lost and Found” By Colson Whitehead. In the article, Whitehead states, I started building my New York on the uptown No. 1 train. My first city memory is of looking out a subway window as the train erupted from the tunnel on the way to 125th Street and palsied up into the elevated tracks.” I could relate to the author, I feel like everyone has their own way of viewing New York. I view downtown Brooklyn different from other people because I grew up in a neighborhood that had more houses than buildings unlike city tech, where there are more movements and more diversity. Also, many people have different experiences depending on where they live. Another article that supports my project is “What If You Could Choose Between The Fastest Route and The Most beautiful?’ by Lex Berko. In the article, the author states, “Your commute to work and your walk to the shop don’t have to be so myopic and destination-driven. If you give yourself 10 extra minutes for a small detour on your journey, it can transform your experience of the city into something altogether more enjoyable.” I agree with the author, personally, I do this all the time. I enjoy taking different routes when I walk from my house to the gym and vice versa. I like taking the long routes because I feel like they put me in a good mood, especially when I’m getting ready to work out I walk by streets that have more trees and where more of nature is seen. I find it more relaxing than walking by noisy traffic; Even though sometimes like to walk where the streets have more pedestrians because It makes it feel less isolated. When I walk to city tech, I take the longer route and I get off at Lawrence street and I walk by Metro Tech Commons because it feels more like a campus and I enjoy seeing people walking their dogs and the large, green trees make the air fresher.

Class Notes 11/5

Library session: What stands out from the library session on 10/31?

  • know the source
  • know how reliable the source can be
  • biased vs unbiased
  • sometimes we don’t get the information directly from the source
  • +sometimes information comes to us instead of us going to get it–we need to question it.
  • academic source–what is it, do we want to use it, why?
    • research article, from a research journal
    • usually written by professors, graduate students, other academic workers,  researchers at related or  non-academic institutions
  • questions about research as you’re doing Project #4 or any other work?
  • does the author get paid? does it matter?

Project #3 drafts:

  1. In one or two sentences, what is your Project #3 about?
  2. What claim or argument do you make? this is the So What of your project.
  3. what is the juxtaposition? what are the two elements you’re comparing?
  4. are you doing all the things that the Project #3 assignment asks for?
  5. when someone reads your draft or listens to you talk about your project, what do you want them to tell you?
    • what is the claim or argument (high order)
    • what stands out or is significant about the juxtaposition
    • does the claim or argument make sense (high order)
    • comparison details: enough, too  much, not enough?
    • make sure you quote 2 passages and incorporate them into your argument about your juxtaposition
    • questions that they want to know more about
    • grammar (low order)
    • sentence structure
    • vocabulary

Project 3- Kami

         The juxtaposition I chose for this project is located on 112 Pierrepont St. From City Tech you would walk to The Supreme Court. From there would walk down Pierrepont St. past the Brooklyn Historic Society. There you will spot a cathedral and a white building across the street from it. The juxtaposition is the old brick cathedral and the new marble building. The contrast between the two is that the cathedral is old fashioned and historic meanwhile the white building is has a more recent and modern feel to it. This white building is actually known as the Supreme Court of the State of New York : Appelate Division and the Cathedral is the First Unitarian Congregational Society in Brooklyn.
         The Appelate Court is a large white building with large brown windows surrounding the perimeter of the building. It has two pillars on either side of the Entrance to the building. This building in particular is interesting because it stands out from it’s juxtaposition and the other buildings in the area. Not only does it appear to be younger than the other buildings but it is also made of another material than the other buildings: Marble. It is the only building on that block that is made of marble whereas the Congregational Society across from it is made of the same material as most of the buildings in the area: Bricks.

         Another juxtaposition the two buildings share is their age. The Appelate Court was built in 1896, while the Congregational Society was built in 1833, making the Cathedral much older than the Court. If you look closely at the state of the two buildings you’ll notice that the Congregational Society looks remarkably older than the Appelate Court. It might’ve been renovated and kept in shape over the years. This contrast in particular reminds of the comparison of routes in the passage “What If You Could Choose Between the Fastest Route and the Most Beautiful”. When the narrator mentions the comparison of the two routes she says that “Mapping Apps are a fantastic tool, but they can be a little soulless.” So the narrator was saying the two routes were very different. The connection I made to my juxtaposition was that the fast route on a road may be boring and dull like the Congregational Society and the Scenic route on a road may be interesting and new like the Appelate Court.

I think that area in general will be drastically changed in the near future. Not too far from that location is a tall, new building that is currently undergoing renovation/construction. Another building that is on Fulton near Jay Street is also being built. The Macy’s building is also in the process of getting renovated. These are just a few examples of some of the different changes that have occurred in the Downtown Brooklyn area since the Construction of the Barclays Center. Ever since then, the area change dramatically new buildings were made and old locations were renovated. before long, It looked like a completely different location. If I wanted to take it further, my own neighbor hood is changing as well. There was a gas station a block away from where I live. One day, I noticed it was closed and over the years I also noticed that it was undergoing construction and eventually changed into a strip mall. Even Kings Plaza, which is not too far from where I live, was changed many stores were removed to make way for new ones and the ones that were still there were contemporized.

Juxtposition

From New York City Tech if you exit from jay street its approximately like 2 blocks going down to fulton. From there you can already see the train station to not just the A train but also the C, F trains. Afterward you have to head to the left of the train station like a block to head to Lawrence and Willoughby street near the R train exit of Jay St-Metro Tech station. There is also this address you can put on google maps to help navigate: 129 Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, this will leave you in the same street.To look for this angle in the photograph you have to look up and see the same design building. There are 3 different buildings the very first is part of the ASA college, the second building is probably connected to the parking lot of the college or of a business place.

Class Notes 10/29

What juxtapositions can we find in Saul Steinberg’s “View of the World from 9th Avenue” or “View of the World from 9th Avenue”?

we see City/Not City

In the City, we see cars, people (but fewer than we might expect), buildings, water towers, windows of different shapes, parking lot, awning, signs, mailbox, highway. No trees or nature.

In the Not City: multiple countries (Mexico, Canada, China, Japan, Russia) with no detail; Jersey has its own color and border; states and cities are jumbled up and wrong details if any details–not accurate

In this piece, Steinberg argues that …

… what’s outside of NY doesn’t matter to him

… no other place could compare to NY

… what’s inside NY is more important than what’s outside

… he can juxtapose the difference in the details and importance.

By juxtaposing the details and importance between New York and the rest of the world, Steinberg argues that no other place can compare to NY, and that NY’s details matter more than anything outside of NY.

As we read and discuss Janny Scott’s “Here, Poverty And Privilege Are Neighbors; Income Gaps Are a Source Of Resentment and Guilt,” work with your classmates to answer these questions:

What kinds of juxtapositions does Scott write about?

  • building style/use
  • economic diversity: people at either extreme of the wealth/poverty spectrum
  • fascination with difference vs resentment and guilt

What kinds of data does Scott use in her article?

  • top 5th and bottom 5th of the income bracket in a given area
  • top 30 tracts with the biggest income disparity
  • census data
  • immigration data, neighborhood demographics both historical and current

Who are the experts Scott refers to, and how does she let us know their qualifications?

  • Academics
    • Andrew A. Beveridge, sociology prof at Queens College, CUNY
    • William Kornblum, sociology prof at the Graduate Center, CUNY
    • David J. Halle, (prof) sociologist at University of California at Los Angeles but living in NYC
    • Annelise Orleck (see below) (prof)  historian at Dartmouth
  • Residents (former or present) of the neighborhoods
    • Chastity Davis
    • Pablo Aviles
    • Annelise Orleck
    • Mary-Powel Thomas

What is Scott’s argument in the article?

What passages might you quote in Project #3?

What would you use those passages to argue?

 

As we think about Project #3 and our juxtapositions, what is your juxtaposition? what is the SO WHAT? What does it matter that you’re looking at this juxtaposition? Why does this juxtaposition matter?

Class on 10/29; Project #3 updates

In class on 10/24, we discussed a revised schedule for Project #3.

This means that if you haven’t already completed the home work due on 10/24, please post it by the start of class on 10/29. Here are the instructions: Find 3-4 passages from the relevant readings that you can use as support or counterpoint for your project and explain how each supports or contradicts you’re your observed overlap. You will incorporate two of these quotations into your project to either to support what you write or to engage their ideas in contrast with your subject and your interpretation of it.

Please also post and bring to class a draft of Project #3, however far you’ve gotten with it. We will workshop the drafts in class and discuss incorporating the passages you discovered for homework as support or counterpoints for your discussion of the juxtaposition you’re writing about.

We also delayed our discussion of Janny Scott’s “Here, Poverty And Privilege Are Neighbors; Income Gaps Are a Source Of Resentment and Guilt”–so please read it and be ready to discuss in class on 10/29.

Questions or concerns? Ask them in reply to this post, or in my office hours, or at the start of class.

Juxtaposition project

To get to this place from city tech, you would walk down adams street towards johnson st. When reaching johnson st, make a left and go to jay street. Then make a right and you”ll find this old looking building. This picture shows juxtaposition by this old looking building being here and in the background a taller newer looking building. The material on the reddish, looking building looks way older than the material on the newer, shinier, blue building in the background. The older building at first was the Brooklyn fire headquarters before turning into a place for affordable housing. it was built in 1892. The building went through a renovation that started in 2013 and ended in 2014

Homework due 10/24

Throughout my walk there was various Juxtapositions but one that stuck out to me the most was “Nature in the City.” New Yorkers including myself no longer observe , were too busy wondering what song will play next or perhaps the latest news on social media , but what about your city ? have we been up to date on what’s going on around us ? Did you notice the dying flowers ? or the trees that are slowly losing their leaves? probably not. In the article “What If You Could Choose Between The Fastest Route And The Most Beautiful” the author stated “If you give yourself and extra 10 minutes for a small detour on your journey, it can transform your experience of the city into something altogether more enjoyable” this like supports my project because it is motivating us to actually observe the city and our surroundings. On the passage “Here,Poverty And privilege are neighbors; income gaps are a source of resentment and guilt” the author states on the last paragraph “But you always get the sense in the back of your head that things would be different if you looked a certain way or had a certain amount of money” if we were to all look at things a certain way or view things into depth and really put thought into it we’ll discover New York City isn’t just a city but its a home, our home its more like a wakeup call. In the article by Colson Whitehead “The way we live now:11-11-01 lost and found” on the third paragraph he states ” The only skyscrapers visible from your carriage were the legs of adults, but you got to know the ground pretty well and started to wonder why some sidewalks sparkle at certain angles” at a very young age we started observing our surroundings and not only that but we started understanding what was what and comparing certain objects or colors and as we grew up it’s like we forgot all about the world and our city we get distracted very easily and I bet nobody knows how many stripes the crosswalk has. It’s very shocking how we have adapted to our own world then Our world.

Juxtaposition

 


This picture illustrates juxtaposition right by city tech. The picture shows a quiet resting place/ park known as Walt Whitman park. That has a bunch of benches, trees and it’s right next to a road where sometimes there can be busy traffic/distractions etc… And although the park is surrounded by what you would normally be a loud area. It’s a place that’s there to help indicate that even in chaos there is also peace.

This is located right outside of the High St, Brooklyn Bridge station. If you took the A/C train to get to city tech rather than getting off at jay st you can take 1 extra stop get off at high street and it’ll be your first right after you exit. Or if you are walking from city tech. You would turn left on tillary, walk to the end of that block, cross over to your right, then cross over the next light, turn right and keep walking straight and it will be on your right.