i believe his arguments are highly convincing. he bring to light the comparisons between the other solders and as well highlights the time frame for when the picture could have been taken. I doubt that Capa’s photograph was fake. It looked well taken and there isn’t any concrete information to show why he would even stage it. Honestly i don’t think authenticity matters especially when it comes to the horrors of war. Whether it is perceived as stage or not the picture helps to illustrate the horrors of war.