This photo is the best one because it shows the depth of field between the shoe and the light ball.Also it shows the rough edges of the shoe at the toe.
This photo is the best one because it shows the depth of field between the shoe and the light ball.Also it shows the rough edges of the shoe at the toe as well as the faded converse logo which gives the shoe more description of it being worn out.
Nice use of framing. I like how you cropped the shoe. the light despite being out of focus remains very important as it is the brightest thing in the photo.