Although Whelan’s builds a good argument to prove Capa’s photo is fake, it does not convince me enough to support it. Capa’s photograph may seem fake to some extent because it only shows the soldier and nothing else or no one around. There is also the argument that there is no gunshot wound shown anywhere in the body which is one of Whelan’s arguments. I argue that death is unique in every way possible so one cannot judge how the soldier is positioned or falling. In Whelan’s argument, there is a close up of the soldiers hand and there is an explanation of how when a person dies the muscle of the body tighten up and the soldiers hand shows just that.
Contact Information
Professor Sandra Cheng
Office: Namm 602B
Office Hours: Mon 10-11 am, Tu/Th 9-10 am or
by appointment
Office Tel: 718-260-5003
Email: scheng@citytech.cuny.eduNew York Times Arts
- The Design Legacy of Los Angeles That Fell to the Fires
- Loving an ‘Untouched’ Modernist House, and Then Getting Down to Work
- With Their Lives Upended, They Practiced the Art of Resilience
- ‘Starry Night,’ All Night Long, as a Van Gogh Blockbuster Ends
- Decades Ago, Students Attacked the ‘Iron Horse.’ Now It Rides Again.
-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- Leidy on Homework #3: Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
- Djane96 on Homework #2: Walker Evans’ Subway Portraits
- Djane96 on Homework #3: Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
- Kelly-Ann on Henry Gomez Homework #3: Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
- Billy on Homework #3: Robert Capa’s Death of a Loyalist Soldier
Archives
Categories
Meta